Jenbug, yours look fine! I think the times are meant to be a guideline for the minimum amount of time to spend on each, so a short taster session during a meeting is absolutely fine, but for phase 2 and 3 it should be more of a personal challenge as well as taking longer. So, e.g. attending a ranger camp might be a phase 2 or even 3 for someone who hasn't camped before, whereas someone else who is older or has camped lots before rangers might not see it as a big challenge and choose to count it for phase 1 instead. Neither would be 'wrong'. Similarly, organising a one night sleepover for brownies might take less time than attending a week long camp as a participant, but still be more of a challenge and counted for a higher octant, if that makes sense?